Airbnb Arbitrage Is Not the Golden Ticket People Say It Is

Let me save you the trouble: Airbnb Arbitrage sounds sexy, but you’ll be running uphill with a backpack full of bricks.

Here’s how Airbnb Arbitrage is supposed to work:

1. Rent a property with a long-term lease (typically one year)

2. List that same property on Airbnb for short-term stays

3. Make a profit when your Airbnb income exceeds your rental costs

For example, if you pay $2,000 monthly rent but earn $3,500 from Airbnb guests, your profit would be $1,500 per month (minus expenses).

Sounds easy, right? Spoiler alert: It’s not. 

But it sure generates a lot of buzz online:

Lets break it down.

The Myth of “Passive Income” Through Airbnb Arbitrage

There’s nothing passive about this scenario. To successfully execute Airbnb Arbitrage, you need:

Step 1: You’ve got to convince a landlord to let you rent their property—knowing you’re subletting it on Airbnb. (This alone is a massive hurdle)

Step 2: Even if you manage that, you’re now on the hook for rent, utilities, insurance, and furnishing costs before you’ve made a single penny. (It takes time to furnish and setup your listing)

Step 3: Speaking of furnishing—think $10k minimum to make a small place Airbnb-ready. Add in professional photos and management software. The meter’s still running.

And we’re not even talking about the operational grind:

• Setting up the listing

• Property management and guest communication

• Cleaning between guests (or paying for it)

• Handling maintenance

• Restocking supplies

• Replacing broken items

Bottom line: Passive income via Airbnb Arbitrage isn’t happening.

The Flaw In The Plan

Sure, Airbnb hosting can be insanely profitable—even with those upfront costs. And maybe you do everything right: find the perfect property, nail every strategy, and start pulling in serious cash through Arbitrage. But here's the fatal flaw in this business model: it's built on borrowed time.

Now think about Airbnb Arbitrage. What’s stopping your landlord from doing the same thing? They see the money you’re making, decide not to renew your lease, and take over your operation. Oh, and guess who’s stuck with all that furniture you bought?

Do People Actually Make Money in Arbitrage?

Have a few people made money doing Airbnb Arbitrage? Sure.

But let’s be real: 99% of people fail over the long term.

It seems like the only people consistently profiting in the Arbitrage space are the ones selling courses on “how to get rich with arbitrage.” (Not hating on how people make a living, but you should know the truth)

As a loyal Host Report reader, consider this your warning: I do not recommend going down this path.

Airbnb Arbitrage = High risk, Low reward.

Most people chasing this path are working with limited capital, hoping to fast-track their way into the Airbnb game. I get it—buying a property is expensive. But if every dollar counts, why gamble on a bad strategy?

There are better ways to break into Airbnb hosting:

• Start with Co-Hosting: No upfront costs. Learn the ropes, earn cash, and build your knowledge base.

• Save Up and Buy Smart: Own your property, and you get all the profits, plus benefits like asset appreciation, tax advantages, and debt leverage.

Airbnb can be wildly profitable. But it’s not a shortcut to riches. It’s a business—and like any business, success comes from hard work, smart decisions, and a willingness to play the long game.

I’ve got plenty more to say on this topic, but I don’t want to bore those who aren’t interested.

If this hits home and you want me to dive deeper (including some hard numbers), reply with “interested” - I’ll make it happen.

New round here? Join the newsletter (its free).