The Superhost Shield: Mastering the 4.8 Star Rule

Don’t let a single bad review cost you bookings. This guide shows you how to identify and remove unfair reviews fast.

Author

Dom Trovato
January 17, 2025

Your Superhost status isn’t just a badge—it’s a competitive advantage in an overcrowded market. It signals trust and influences booking decisions.

To keep it, you need an average rating of at least 4.8 stars. Drop below 4.3, and Airbnb could suspend or even remove your listing.

Here’s the harsh truth: letting a bad review slide is like handing your competition a golden ticket. Reviews drive bookings—period.

That’s why every sub-5-star review deserves scrutiny. And it's smart to try and find a case for removal whenever possible. 

But don’t waste time yelling, “UNFAIR!” at an Airbnb support rep—you'll never get a review removed that way.

The secret? If the guest’s review even slightly violates Airbnb’s policies, they’re required to remove it.

Here’s The Playbook

To remove a bad review, think less like a frustrated host and more like a lawyer:

  1. Document Everything: Collect evidence to support your claim.

  2. Review Airbnb’s Policies: Highlight specific violations in the review.

  3. Present Your Case Professionally: Communicate clearly and concisely.

  4. Provide Evidence: Attach documentation and cite policy violations directly.

Make it easy for Airbnb’s support team to say, “Yeah, you’re right—this review has to go.”

Here’s a great example of a host who nailed it:

What this host did right

  1. Professional Tone: No rants, no drama—just clear, concise communication.

  2. Solid Documentation: Attached evidence to back up their claim.

  3. Direct Request: Politely but firmly asked for the review’s removal.

  4. Used Airbnb’s Policies: They quoted Airbnb’s own rules to build their case.

Big respect to this host for playing it smart and protecting their business.

Why This Matters

Most hosts ignore the fine print in Airbnb’s policies—or don’t know how to use them to their advantage. Don’t be most hosts. Your reputation is the backbone of your business.

Think of this email as your bad review insurance. Learn now while things are running smoothly so you can act fast if trouble strikes.

Want templates?

I’ve written step-by-step guides on how to handle review removals, complete with Airbnb policy citations and templates you can use when contacting Airbnb support. Check out these articles:

Get those negative reviews removed quicker than a guest texts you about the Wi-Fi password.

Does this topic interest you? Hit reply and let me know—every reply comes straight to me. If you find this helpful, I’ll keep ‘em coming.

Remember: every star counts. Don’t let a bad review stick around longer than it has to.

New round here? Join the newsletter (its free).